Comparison numbers

	15	Products researched
	5	Research hours
	370	Readers
	72,192	Customer ratings

Best Eyeliners

Eyeliner Comparison 2025

Sort & Filter

Best Product

Manhattan 1010N

Manhattan 1010N

Amazon

Maybelline Lasting Drama

Maybelline Lasting Drama

Amazon

Bestseller

Maybelline Lasting Drama

Maybelline Lasting Drama

Amazon

L'Oreal Superliner Perfect Slim

L'Oreal Superliner Perfect Slim

Amazon

ARTDECO eyeliner

ARTDECO eyeliner

Amazon

L'Oreal eyeliner

L'Oreal eyeliner

Amazon

Max Factor Colour X-Pert Waterproof

Max Factor Colour X-Pert Waterproof

Amazon

RatingHow we compare

Customer rating (from Amazon)

Available at

Manufacturer

Quantity

Colour

Consistency

Opacity

Skin types

Effect

Without mineral oil

Vegan

Packaging

Shipping (Amazon)

Best Product

Best Product

Manhattan 1010N

Rating

1

Manhattan 1010N

Customer rating

5,153 reviews

Check Price

Available at

see vendordays

see vendordays00£

Manufacturer

Manhattan

Quantity

1,3 g

Colour

Sand

Consistency

Creamy

Opacity

Skin types

Effect

Without mineral oil

Vegan

Packaging

Pen

Shipping (Amazon)

see vendor

Check Price

Maybelline Lasting Drama

Rating

2

Maybelline Lasting Drama

Customer rating

7,611 reviews

Check Price

Available at

see vendordays00£

see vendordays00£

see vendordays00£

Manufacturer

Maybelline

Quantity

3 g

Colour

Sand

Consistency

Hard

Opacity

Strong, Medium

Skin types

Effect

Without mineral oil

Vegan

Packaging

Pen, Crucible

Shipping (Amazon)

see vendor

Check Price

Bestseller

Bestseller

Maybelline Lasting Drama

Rating

3

Maybelline Lasting Drama

Customer rating

4,883 reviews

Check Price

Available at

see vendordays00£

see vendordays1.551.55£

Manufacturer

Maybelline

Quantity

2,5 ml

Colour

Sand

Consistency

Hard, Runny

Opacity

Strong, Medium

Skin types

All skin types

Effect

Drip tray

Without mineral oil

Vegan

Packaging

Pen

Shipping (Amazon)

see vendor

Check Price

L'Oreal Superliner Perfect Slim

Rating

4

L'Oreal Superliner Perfect Slim

Customer rating

9,731 reviews

Check Price

Available at

see vendordays00£

see vendordays00£

see vendordays5.995.99£

see vendordays3.993.99£

see vendordays5.115.11£

see vendordays00£

Manufacturer

L'Oreal

Quantity

9,2 ml

Colour

Sand, Light

Consistency

Hard, Runny

Opacity

Strong, Medium

Skin types

Normal skin

Effect

Without mineral oil

Vegan

Packaging

Pen

Shipping (Amazon)

see vendor

Check Price

ARTDECO eyeliner

Rating

5

ARTDECO eyeliner

Customer rating

917 reviews

Check Price

Available at

see vendordays

see vendordays66£

see vendordays2.992.99£

see vendordays5.115.11£

Manufacturer

ARTDECO

Quantity

31 ml

Colour

Rosé, Rose, Light, Sand

Consistency

Creamy, Hard

Opacity

Strong

Skin types

Effect

Active care

Without mineral oil

Vegan

Packaging

Pen

Shipping (Amazon)

see vendor

Check Price

L'Oreal eyeliner

Rating

6

L'Oreal eyeliner

Customer rating

1,014 reviews

Check Price

Available at

see vendordays

see vendordays00£

Manufacturer

L'Oreal

Quantity

3 ml

Colour

Consistency

Creamy, Hard

Opacity

Skin types

Effect

Without mineral oil

Vegan

Packaging

Pen

Shipping (Amazon)

see vendor

Check Price

Max Factor Colour X-Pert Waterproof

Rating

7

Max Factor Colour X-Pert Waterproof

Customer rating

1,357 reviews

Check Price

Available at

see vendordays00£

see vendordays00£

see vendordays00£

see vendordays3.993.99£

Manufacturer

Max Factor

Quantity

4,2 ml

Colour

Rose, Rosé

Consistency

Hard, Runny

Opacity

Strong

Skin types

All skin types

Effect

Drip tray

Without mineral oil

Vegan

Packaging

Pen

Shipping (Amazon)

see vendor

Check Price

Similar categories

Cosmetics

Cosmetics

Eyelash curler

Open comparison

Cosmetics

Cosmetics

Mascara

Open comparison

Cosmetics

Cosmetics

Primer

Open comparison

Cosmetics

Cosmetics

Lipstick

Open comparison

Cosmetics

Cosmetics

Concealer stick

Open comparison

Website only uses essential cookies: these cookies are required for the operation of the website. Users cannot deactivate essential cookies (except in browser). For further information, refer to privacy policy.