Comparison numbers

22 Products researched
23 Research hours
3,100 Readers
135,519 Customer ratings

Best Mascaras

Mascara Comparison 2025

eyelash curler
eyelash curler
 eyeliner
eyeliner
 mascara
mascara
 eyeshadow
eyeshadow
 magnetic eyelash
magnetic eyelash
Sort & Filter
Best Product
Maybelline The Colossal 100% Black
Maybelline The Colossal 100% Black
Amazon
L'Oreal Volume Million Lashes
L'Oreal Volume Million Lashes
Amazon
Bestseller
Gaya Cosmetics Mascara
Gaya Cosmetics Mascara
Amazon
L'Oreal Voluminous Paradise Extatic
L'Oreal Voluminous Paradise Extatic
Amazon
Clinique New-130160
Clinique New-130160
Amazon
L'Oreal mascara
L'Oreal mascara
Amazon
Best Price
Max Factor 2000 Calorie
Max Factor 2000 Calorie
Amazon
RatingHow we compare
Customer rating (from Amazon)
Available at
Manufacturer
Quantity
Volumen
Waterproof
Finish
Without mineral oil
Without perfume
Without animal testing
Vegan
Advantages
Shipping (Amazon)
Best Product
Best Product
AmazonMaybelline The Colossal 100% Black
Rating
Excellent01/2025

1

Maybelline The Colossal 100% Black
Customer rating
Amazon11,619 reviews
Check Price
Available at
6,15 £
see vendordays00£
11,21 £
see vendordays00£
13,99 £
1-2 dayday00£
Manufacturer
Maybelline
Quantity
11 ml
Volumen
Waterproof
Finish
Matt
Without mineral oil
Without perfume
Without animal testing
Vegan
Advantages
Shipping (Amazon)
1-2 day
Check Price
AmazonL'Oreal Volume Million Lashes
Rating
Excellent05/2025

2

L'Oreal Volume Million Lashes
Customer rating
Amazon16,242 reviews
Check Price
Available at
9,47 £
see vendordays00£
10,49 £
see vendordays00£
7,99 £
4 daysdays2.52.5£
6,99 £
see vendordays5.995.99£
10,80 £
4 daysdays3.993.99£
10,39 £
see vendordays5.785.78£
Manufacturer
L'Oreal
Quantity
11,5 ml
Volumen
Waterproof
Finish
Matt
Without mineral oil
Without perfume
Without animal testing
Vegan
Advantages
Shipping (Amazon)
see vendor
Check Price
Bestseller
Bestseller
AmazonGaya Cosmetics Mascara
Rating
Excellent05/2025

3

Gaya Cosmetics Mascara
Customer rating
Amazon7,067 reviews
Check Price
Available at
16,95 £
see vendordays00£
21,68 £
see vendordays00£
Manufacturer
Quantity
Volumen
Waterproof
Finish
Without mineral oil
Without perfume
Without animal testing
Vegan
Advantages
  • Made without animal testing
Shipping (Amazon)
see vendor
Check Price
AmazonL'Oreal Voluminous Paradise Extatic
Rating
Excellent01/2025

4

L'Oreal Voluminous Paradise Extatic
Customer rating
Amazon37,254 reviews
Check Price
Available at
8,01 £
see vendordays00£
7,95 £
see vendordays00£
5,90 £
4 daysdays3.93.9£
11,75 £
see vendordays00£
9,40 £
4 daysdays3.993.99£
9,07 £
see vendordays5.995.99£
Manufacturer
L'Oreal
Quantity
9,1 ml
Volumen
Waterproof
Finish
Matt
Without mineral oil
Without perfume
Without animal testing
Vegan
Advantages
Shipping (Amazon)
see vendor
Check Price
AmazonClinique New-130160
Rating
Excellent01/2025

5

Clinique New-130160
Customer rating
Amazon7,400 reviews
Check Price
Available at
19,53 £
see vendordays00£
12,92 £
see vendordays00£
12,59 £
5 daysdays3.953.95£
14,87 £
see vendordays5.995.99£
21,80 £
4 daysdays3.993.99£
22,32 £
see vendordays5.785.78£
Manufacturer
Clinique
Quantity
828 ml
Volumen
Waterproof
Finish
Matt
Without mineral oil
Without perfume
Without animal testing
Vegan
Advantages
  • Perfume is not included
Shipping (Amazon)
see vendor
Check Price
AmazonL'Oreal mascara
Rating
Excellent05/2025

6

L'Oreal mascara
Customer rating
Amazon4,290 reviews
Check Price
Available at
13,99 £
see vendordays00£
16,52 £
see vendordays00£
10,99 £
see vendordays00£
Manufacturer
L'Oreal
Quantity
15,2 ml
Volumen
Waterproof
Finish
Without mineral oil
Without perfume
Without animal testing
Vegan
Advantages
Shipping (Amazon)
see vendor
Check Price
Best Price
Best Price
AmazonMax Factor 2000 Calorie
Rating
Excellent05/2025

7

Max Factor 2000 Calorie
Customer rating
Amazon11,878 reviews
Check Price
Available at
5,05 £
see vendordays00£
6,58 £
see vendordays00£
7,85 £
see vendordays00£
Manufacturer
Max Factor
Quantity
11 ml
Volumen
Waterproof
Finish
Glossy, Matt
Without mineral oil
Without perfume
Without animal testing
Vegan
Advantages
  • Contains no perfume
Shipping (Amazon)
see vendor
Check Price

Similar categories

Cosmetics
Cosmetics
BB cream
Open comparison
Cosmetics
Cosmetics
Eyeliner
Open comparison
Cosmetics
Cosmetics
Concealer stick
Open comparison
Cosmetics
Cosmetics
Primer
Open comparison
Cosmetics
Cosmetics
Eyeshadow
Open comparison
Website only uses essential cookies: these cookies are required for the operation of the website. Users cannot deactivate essential cookies (except in browser). For further information, refer to privacy policy.